The commute from Hicksville Long Island vs Jackson Heights Queens compared reveals a key difference: as of November 2024, the average LIRR train ride from Hicksville to Penn Station takes around 45 minutes, while the E, F, M, or R subway from Jackson Heights to Midtown Manhattan averages just 25 minutes. This time gap can add up quickly for daily commuters and is crucial for those balancing work and family life across boroughs.
As of November 2024, rental prices in Jackson Heights have remained steady, with one-bedroom flats averaging £2,150 per month, while Hicksville offers slightly larger spaces for about £2,400, but with more limited public transport options. If you are weighing affordability against convenience, know that Jackson Heights offers easier access to ethnic groceries and late-night services, whereas Hicksville’s quieter setting may appeal if you prefer less urban density—but you’ll need a car for most errands.
One practical tip: If you plan to rely on public transport, Jackson Heights’ 74th Street–Roosevelt Avenue transit hub makes transfers simple, while Hicksville’s LIRR station is excellent for city-bound travel but far from most shopping and dining. This matters because daily logistics—like childcare pickups, shopping, or shift work—can become unexpectedly complicated if you underestimate transfer times or parking limitations.
This guide delivers three outcomes: a side-by-side comparison of Hicksville Long Island vs Jackson Heights Queens compared costs and commute realities; up-to-date 2024 insights on schools, amenities, and neighbourhood safety; and concrete advice for new immigrants choosing between the two. You will leave with a clear understanding of which location matches your priorities and how to avoid newcomer mistakes in your NYC move.
Overview of Hicksville Long Island and Jackson Heights Queens
If you’re sizing up Hicksville Long Island vs Jackson Heights Queens for a move in 2024, buckle up. These two NYC enclaves couldn’t be more distinct—one’s classic suburban Nassau County, the other’s Queens at its most vibrant. Hicksville sits about 27 miles east of Manhattan, a terminal on the LIRR’s Port Jefferson line. You can ride from Penn Station or Grand Central Madison in about 42 minutes on a good day—if the MTA gods smile and you’ve reloaded your MetroCard. Out here, you get detached houses, ample parking, and strip malls galore, but don’t expect sidewalk life or bodegas on every corner. Average rents for a two-bedroom hover near $2,800/month in 2024; single-family homes are flirting with $650,000.
v>
Jackson Heights, meanwhile, is pure Queens density—prewar co-ops, six-story walk-ups, and a street life that never pauses. Diversity isn’t just a buzzword here; Roosevelt Avenue is a United Nations of food and languages. Hop the 7, E, F, M, or R at 74th Street–Broadway and you’ll hit Manhattan in 25 minutes, barring 2024’s constant track work. Rentals average $2,600/month for a one-bedroom, and you’ll wait in line at Patel Brothers on weekends—guaranteed.
| Neighbourhoodh> | Main Transith> | 2024 Rent (2BR)h> | Commute to Midtownh> |
|---|---|---|---|
| Hicksvilled> | LIRR Port Jeffersond> | $2,800/monthd> | ~42 minutes (Penn Station)d>
r> |
| Jackson Heightsd> | 7, E, F, M, R subwayd> | $2,600/monthd> | ~25 minutes (Times Sq)d>
📋 Quick Reference | g>
|
Comparison of Residential Neighborhoods in Hicksville and Jackson Heights
If you’re weighing up Hicksville Long Island vs Jackson Heights Queens in 2024, brace for a classic NYC contrast. Hicksville, out in Nassau County, feels like suburban New York’s answer to the city hustle—wide streets, detached homes, and that LIRR commute (40 minutes to Penn Station if you catch the right train). In contrast, Jackson Heights, perched in northern Queens and just a few express stops from Manhattan on the E, F, R, or 7, is an urban patchwork—pre-war co-ops, walk-ups, and the kind of diversity you taste in every bodega samosa. Here, “neighbourhood” means a block where six languages and three religions live in peace above the same laundromat.
v>
Let’s talk living costs. In 2024, Jackson Heights offers one-bedrooms for $2,400/month, with co-op options at $350,000–$550,000. Hicksville’s single-family homes list from $650,000 and up—think mortgage, not MetroCard. Schools? Hicksville High is steady, while Jackson Heights families angle for PS 69 or IS 145, both known for strong ESOL support. If your family’s got roots in India, Colombia, or Bangladesh, both areas feel like home—but Jackson Heights’ bustling 37th Ave and late-night sari shops are legendary.
| Featureh> | Hicksvilleh> | Jackson Heightsh> |
|---|---|---|
| Typical Housingd> | Detached houses, drivewaysd> | Co-ops, walk-ups, pre-ward>
r> |
| Transit Accessd> | LIRR (Penn Station, 40 min)d> | Subway: E, F, R, 7 linesd>
r> |
| Median Rent (2024)d> | $3,200/month (house)d> | $2,400/month (1BR)d>
r> |
| Nearest Shopping Stripd> | Broadway Mall, Route 107d> | 37th Ave, Diversity Plazad>
📋 Quick Referenceg>
|
Cost of Living and Housing Options in Hicksville and Jackson Heights
If you’re weighing Hicksville Long Island vs Jackson Heights Queens, the cost of living will hit you hard—especially in 2024, with inflation still casting its shadow on every bodega and brownstone. Jackson Heights (E, F, M, R, 7 trains at Roosevelt Ave–74th St) means convenient subway access to Manhattan, but you’ll pay for that privilege. Rents hover around $2,400/month for a one-bedroom. Hicksville, Nassau County—where the LIRR whisks you to Manhattan in under 50 minutes from 101 Newbridge Rd—offers more space but with a commuter trade-off. Expect $2,000/month for a one-bedroom, though you’ll probably want a car, which means shelling out for parking and insurance. For families, two-bedroom rentals in Jackson Heights can top $3,200, while in Hicksville they sit closer to $2,600, with the bonus of backyard BBQs and quieter streets.
- Jackson Heights median rent in 2024: $2,400 for a one-bedroomi>
- Hicksville median rent in 2024: $2,000 for a one-bedroomi>
- Average monthly MetroCard: $132 (Queens)i>
- LIRR monthly pass (Hicksville to Penn): $325i>l>
v>
Utilities and groceries are somewhat cheaper in Queens—think $160/month for basic utilities compared to $210/month in Hicksville, where suburban sprawl hits your heating bill. Both areas have diverse food options, but Jackson Heights’ 37th Avenue is a paradise for immigrant cuisines and affordable produce. If you’re new to NYC, beware: application fees, paperwork, and co-op board interviews can drag out for weeks, especially in Queens’ pre-war buildings.
⚠️ Warningg>- Hicksville leases often require proof of higher income due to stricter suburban landlord policiesi>
- Jackson Heights co-ops may involve lengthy board approval, sometimes 4–6 weeksi>l>
v>
Ultimately, your choice boils down to subway convenience versus suburban sprawl, and whether your wallet—and patience—can handle NYC’s legendary housing hustle.
Areah> 1BR Renth> Commute Optionsh> Monthly Transit Costh> Jackson Heightsd> $2,400d> Subway (E, F, M, R, 7)d> $132 MetroCardd> r>
Hicksvilled> $2,000d> LIRR, car neededd> $325 LIRR passd> r>y>r>d>e>v>
💰 Money Saverg>- Consider off-peak LIRR tickets in Hicksville for significant monthly savings, especially if working hybrid schedulesi>l>
v>
- Consider off-peak LIRR tickets in Hicksville for significant monthly savings, especially if working hybrid schedulesi>l>
Community Demographics and Cultural Diversity in Hicksville and Jackson Heights
When you talk about community demographics and cultural diversity, Hicksville Long Island and Jackson Heights Queens couldn’t feel more distinct—even though they’re both very much “New York.” In Hicksville, the primary keyword “Hicksville Long Island vs Jackson Heights Queens” comes alive in the daily rhythm: you’ll notice a strong South Asian presence, especially Indian and Pakistani families, blended with historic Italian and Irish roots. The LIRR zips you from Hicksville station straight into Penn Station in Manhattan in about 40 minutes, appealing to commuters seeking suburban calm with city access. Most residents own cars, but MetroCard culture is catching on as more young professionals arrive in 2024, drawn by single-family homes averaging $680,000 and quieter streets than Queens.
v>
Jackson Heights, by contrast, is a living, breathing United Nations. Walking Roosevelt Avenue between 74th Street–Broadway (E, F, M, R, 7 trains) and 82nd Street, you’ll hear Spanish, Bengali, Nepali, Tibetan, and Tagalog—all in one block. Renters dominate, with median rents around $2,350 for a two-bedroom in early 2024. Here, the “bodega” is both convenience store and social hub, where you buy groceries, hear the latest Mets gossip, and debate MetroCard price hikes ($2.90 a swipe as of 2024) with your neighbours.
| Neighbourhoodh> | Main Languagesh> | Housing Typeh> | Transit Optionsh> |
|---|---|---|---|
| Hicksvilled> | English, Hindi, Punjabid> | Single-family homesd> | LIRR, local busesd>
r> |
| Jackson Heightsd> | Spanish, Bengali, Nepalid> | Pre-war co-ops, apartmentsd> | Subway (E, F, M, R, 7), busesd>
📋 Quick Referenceg>
|
Factors to Consider When Choosing Between Hicksville and Jackson Heights
When deciding between Hicksville Long Island and Jackson Heights Queens in 2024, you’re not just picking a location—you’re choosing a lifestyle, commute, and community vibe. The primary keyword here is “Hicksville Long Island vs Jackson Heights Queens,” and trust me, the differences go beyond the LIRR timetables and subway maps. If you’re commuting to Manhattan, Jackson Heights has the 7, E, F, M, and R trains at Roosevelt Avenue–74th Street, with rides to Midtown clocking in around 30 minutes. Hicksville’s LIRR station offers direct service to Penn Station or Grand Central Madison, typically 40-50 minutes, but factor in $13.50 peak fares compared to a $2.90 MetroCard swipe.
| Neighbourhoodh> | Median Rent (1BR)h> | Commute to Midtownh> | Diversity Index (2024)h> |
|---|---|---|---|
| Jackson Heightsd> | $2,400/monthd> | ~30 min (Subway)d> | High (over 60 languages)d>
r> |
| Hicksvilled> | $2,000/monthd> | ~45 min (LIRR)d> | Moderate (South Asian focus)d>
r>y>r>d>e>v> Food and shopping are a world apart. In Jackson Heights, Roosevelt Avenue bustles with Colombian bakeries, Tibetan momo carts, and 24-hour bodegas. Hicksville’s Broadway caters to South Asian tastes, with grocery stores like Patel Brothers and dosa spots. If you work late, note that LIRR service tapers after 11pm, while the subway runs all night—albeit with those infamous weekend delays. ⚠️ Warningg>
Jackson Heights street parking is a daily struggle, especially after 6pm, while Hicksville offers more driveways and garages but fewer walkable amenities.v> School quality, immigration support centres, and seasonal events (like the Jackson Heights Queens Pride Parade in June or Hicksville’s Diwali Mela each autumn) also shape your experience. Ultimately, weigh your priorities: seamless city access, cultural scene, affordability, and—let’s be real—how many hours you want to spend wedged into the E train at rush hour. 📋 Quick Referenceg>
|
You now have a clear understanding of how Hicksville Long Island compares to Jackson Heights Queens in terms of lifestyle, affordability, and community atmosphere for 2024. This knowledge enables you to make more informed decisions whether you’re considering a move, investment, or simply exploring your options, all within a realistic timeframe and budget.
Your first step is to identify your priorities—whether it’s commuting convenience, housing costs, or local amenities—and then visit both areas to get a firsthand feel. Scheduling a visit early next month can help you gather insights and determine which neighbourhood aligns best with your needs.
Have questions or want to share your thoughts? We’d love to hear from you. For more insights on moving and neighbourhood comparisons, check our detailed guide on indonewyork.com.
